Audit & Financial Valuation · AFV Musrefy Award 2026
Audit & Assurance Award
Honours quality, independence and adherence to standards in audit and assurance work.
How this award is scored
- Evaluation
- 100% automatic, from the data and evidence you submit
- Minimum score to win
- 75 / 100
- Measurement period
- The last full financial year (2025); for inspection and independence results, the last 36 months
Who can apply
- An audit firm licensed by the competent professional or regulatory body in its country
- Auditing at least three public interest entities (banks, insurers or listed companies) during the period
- Practising for at least five years
- No final material regulatory or judicial sanction against the nominee during the measurement period
Indicators and weights
-
20%
Oversight inspection result
Result of the latest inspection by the audit oversight body or regulator within 36 months
Points
- No significant deficiencies100
- Minor findings only70
- Significant deficiencies remediated and closed30
- Significant deficiencies still open0
Evidence
Oversight body's letter or report on the inspection
-
15%
Internal quality review pass rate
Share of engagement files reviewed under the firm's internal quality management system (ISQM 1) in 2025 rated satisfactory without significant findings
Points
- 97 – < 100 % 100
- 90 – < 97 % 80
- 80 – < 90 % 50
- 0 – < 80 % 20
Evidence
Quality management monitoring report signed by the responsible partner
-
15%
Restatement rate
Share of public interest clients that restated statements previously audited by the firm because of a material error in the last 36 months
Points
- 3 – < 100 % 10
- 1.5 – < 3 % 40
- 0.5 – < 1.5 % 70
- 0 – < 0.5 % 100
Evidence
List of public interest clients with the responsible partner's declaration and disclosure links
-
15%
Independence breaches
Number of independence breaches found internally or by the oversight body in the last 36 months
Points
- ≥ 3 0
- 1 – < 3 50
- 0 – < 1 100
Evidence
Independence register and transparency report
-
10%
Professionally qualified share
Share of professional audit staff holding a recognised qualification (CPA, CA, ACCA, SOCPA, CIA or equivalent) at end-2025
Points
- 50 – < 100 % 100
- 35 – < 50 % 80
- 20 – < 35 % 50
- 0 – < 20 % 20
Evidence
List of professional staff and their qualifications
-
10%
CPD hours per professional
Average documented continuing professional development hours per professional employee in 2025
Points
- ≥ 60 hours 100
- 40 – < 60 hours 80
- 20 – < 40 hours 50
- 0 – < 20 hours 20
Evidence
CPD register
-
10%
Reports issued by the regulatory deadline
Share of audit reports for public interest clients issued before the regulatory publication deadline in 2025
Points
- 99 – < 100 % 100
- 95 – < 99 % 80
- 85 – < 95 % 50
- 0 – < 85 % 20
Evidence
List of reports with signing dates and regulatory deadlines
-
5%
Transparency report
Publishing an annual transparency report with audit quality indicators and the governance structure
Points
- Published100
- Not published0
Evidence
Link to the published transparency report
Each indicator gives 0 to 100 points; its share of the total is its weight. Ties are decided by the indicators listed first in the scorecard; payment or package never affects the score.
Cycle timeline
-
Done
Nominations open
-
Upcoming
Nominations close
-
Upcoming
Judging starts
-
Upcoming
Judging ends
-
Upcoming
Results announced
Times are in Asia/Riyadh (UTC+03:00).
Results
Results are announced only after final approval.